Skip to main content
Man playing chess, a metaphor for scoring competitors before setting a price

Table Of Contents

POSCO: how to price when competitors charge anything from $20 to $5,000

Disclosure: City Profit builds the POSCO method and sells services based on it. The street and its cafes are invented. The table is a real tab from our own financial model. The coffee example comes from a roaster case in our library.

POSCO is how we price a product when competitors charge anything from 20 to 5,000. You score every competitor on five pillars, score yourself honestly, and let the market’s price per point draw a corridor for your price.

A street lined with colourful shop signs, each one competing for the same customer

Three ways to price that fail

  • Copy the cheapest competitor. You inherit their margin problem and none of their customers.
  • Cost plus 30%. The customer has never seen your costs and does not care about them.
  • Ask three friends. Friends tell you what feels kind, and kindness rounds prices down.

POSCO replaces all three with a map, a table and one formula. Three passes, about an hour in total.

Pass 1: draw the street

Customers do not score you on five weights. They feel two things: do I trust these people, and is it easy to buy from them. Draw those two axes, put every competitor where a customer would put them, then place your own sticker.

Drag the red sticker. Then ask two questions: where is the empty space, and what would it take to stand there?

Look at where the stickers crowd. Two cafes fight over the top-right corner, where trust and ease meet. The bottom-right holds one trusted cafe that is hard to use, and the whole left half is thin. Perhaps a gap is a niche, perhaps it is a place nobody wants. The table in pass 2 tells you which.

Pass 2: score them like a judge

POSCO has five pillars: Product, Online presence, Service, Company brand and Offline presence. Each gets a weight that sums to 100 with the others. Our English-language model uses 35, 30, 20, 10 and 5. The Ukrainian one uses 35, 25, 20, 15 and 5, because in a small market people recommend by name and brand weighs more.

Below is the POSCO tab of the model we built for our own product. Six rows, five pillars, one total.

MOMO – Financial Model (EN).xlsx
ABCDEFGHI
2CompetitorURLP (35)1O (30)S (20)C (10)Off (5)SumMain product price3
3Bplanswww.bplans.com2829149282Free library
4LivePlanwww.liveplan.com3127179387$20/mo
5Upmetricsupmetrics.co2722166273$7-25/mo
6Growthinkwww.growthink.com2521157270Templates $67 / done-for-you
7Wise Business Planswisebusinessplans.com2620167372$1,500-5,000+
8MOMO (B)2momohero.com3021133370492 EUR
SUPABCRFunnelsBFMPOSCO
Tab 6 of the six-tab model. The Sum column is a weighted total out of 100.
  1. The weights come first. Fix them for your market before you score anyone, or you will tune them to flatter yourself.
  2. Your own row is scored honestly. Product 30, the same as the best competitor. Brand 3 out of 10, because the brand is new. Nobody invests in a table where the founder leads on every pillar.
  3. The price column mixes units. A free library, a monthly subscription, a one-off template and an agency project are not the same product. Compare price per point only inside one group.
  4. The total can be lower than the leader’s. Here it is 70 against 87, and the model says so out loud. The gap is what the price has to respect.
Three coloured price tags laid side by side

Pass 3: turn points into a price

The POSCO formula

price = our points x (competitor price / competitor points)

Run it for two or three competitors from the same group, take the lowest, the average and the highest. That is your corridor. The calculator is pre-filled with a Brooklyn roaster that sells a bag of beans. Change the numbers to yours.

Your price corridor

Points are weighted totals from your POSCO table. Prices are for the same unit: here one 12 oz bag.

–our total points
–corridor: low end
–corridor: average
–corridor: high end
–your planned price
Enter the points and at least one competitor with points and price. Your price sits inside the corridor. The market will read it as fair. Above the corridor. That can work, but you need a stated reason a buyer can check: freshness, a guarantee, a unique ingredient. Expect fewer buyers. Below the corridor. You are leaving money on the table, or the market sees a risk you have not named.

In the roaster case the formula pointed to about 15 to 17 USD. The founder priced the bag at 19, citing small-batch roasting and freshness, and accepted a smaller first-year volume.

A price is a decision, not a result

POSCO gives a corridor, not a number. Where you stand inside it, or whether you step outside, is strategy. A new brand with a proven product prices near the bottom to win its first hundred buyers. A brand with a visible reason to be different prices above.

Where POSCO is weak

Scoring is judgement. Let two people score separately and average.

Price per point assumes like for like. A subscription and a one-off pack do not mix.

What to do about it

Product A has no competitors in our table. Its price is anchored to what the buyer would spend building it alone, for example hiring a team for four to six months. See the ABCR ladder.

Our view

Most founders score themselves 8 out of 10 everywhere. A table where you lead on every pillar is a table nobody believes, investors included. A low honest score on brand is the most credible number in the document.

POSCO next to the methods you know

Method
What it does
Where POSCO differs
Perceptual mapping
Plots brands on two axes as customers see them.
POSCO uses the map for pass 1, then adds weights and a number.
Feature comparison grid
Ticks features competitors have.
POSCO scores five pillars with weights and ends in a total, not in ticks.
Cost-plus pricing
Adds a margin to your costs.
POSCO starts from the market. Costs come later, in SUP, as a check.
Value-based pricing
Prices by the value the buyer gets.
POSCO is the market-side half. Value-based thinking is used for A, where no competitor exists.

The competitor set comes from your niche, and the sentence next to the price comes from your Core Offer. The same table appears as a slide in the pitch deck. We build these tables for clients at Bizon Planner and teach them at mdopen.pro.

The City Profit technologies series

Previous: Core Offer | Next: SUP | Overview: the seven-step go-to-market guide | All technologies

FAQ

What does POSCO stand for?

Product, Online presence, Service, Company brand and Offline presence: the five pillars used to score every competitor and yourself.

How many competitors do I need?

Five or six for the table, and at least two or three from the same price group for the formula. Fewer than three makes the corridor unreliable.

Why do the weights differ between your models?

The weights describe the market. In the English-language model online presence weighs 30, in the Ukrainian model brand weighs 15 because buyers recommend by name in a smaller market.

What if I have no direct competitors?

Then anchor the price to what the buyer would spend doing it alone, such as the cost of hiring a team. That is how we price product A in the ABCR ladder.

How do I score myself honestly?

Score yourself as you would be seen two months after launch, not on the day of your dream. Ask two outsiders to score you and average with your own.

Sources and further reading

  1. Perceptual mapping (Wikipedia)
  2. Cost-plus pricing (Wikipedia)
  3. Competitor analysis (Wikipedia)
  4. Overview: how to build a B2B offer and go-to-market strategy

Want this done on your numbers? Book a free 30-minute audit with Volodymyr Pimenov.

Book the free auditSee City Profit services

More materials by CITY PROFIT.

CITY PROFIT TRADEMARK. 3080422932. UA